Wednesday, November 9, 2011


Norman Daniels, a philosopher attended the University today to present a lecture called, ““The Hewett Conference on International Migration of Health Care Workers.” The lecture presented arguments and points about the issues of hiring immigrants or recruiting them to work as health care workers. The presentation started off by discussing the right that everyone has to migrate. Basically, every person has a right to leave his or her country and return. However, this is not a free pass for anyone to go anywhere. The country has to be a willing recipient. In summary, it does not give a person an open door to anywhere.
            Generally, developing countries are willing to let immigration happen when it involves health care workers. There is always a shortage of nurses, so recruiting people from the developing countries definitely goes on. This can lead to good or bad things. The majority of the time was spent talking about the Models and how they affect the “brain drain” of the developing countries. In reality, brain drain is happening. Infrastructure of a health care system is the basis of a good health care system, but the developed countries are taking the people that are willing or capable of being trained.  Yes, the individuals need to be trained, but should there be a law stating that they have to go back. I am sure that people that come here are going to want to stay depending on the situation they came from, but should developed countries be allowed to recruit and keep these workers. It seems the developing countries are becoming better and the poor and becoming poorer and in worse shape. There is no balance, but one sure needs to be found. 

3 comments:

  1. Migration is a very complex and interesting issue. In some ways, I agree that there needs to be a push to get healthcare workers back to their country of origin once they have been trained in other countries. Healthcare workers need to be distributed well throughout the world. However, having laws mandating that people return after training seems a bit harsh. While such laws would be effective in reducing the brain drain, it would have other consequences such as less income being sent back to families by the member abroad as well as others.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think this is a really controversial topic because I can see the benefits of both sides. I believe migration is a great thing and everyone should have the right, but sometimes there are limitations. If developed countries bring people in to help her and do medical aid that is awesome because it is helping out our country, but at the same time it is taking away from the country they came from. If developed countries take all the good workers and allow them to migrate here, developing countries will be losing all the workers they need. Migration can be beneficial in bringing in workers, but sad because of the counties losing the aid they need.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a very interesting discussion. There are good points for both sides. A developing country needs healthcare workers to help raise their country. At the same time, the conditions that healthcare worker are in and how they are treated are unfair. If developing countries put more effort to addressing the needs of healthcare workers, more would be willing to stay in their own country. The government should change plans to provide for their needs.

    ReplyDelete